OK, I bought a treadmill.
I took a look at the options (treadmill, The Mall, gym) and decided that, for me, a treadmill was the best choice. While my wife was gently nudging me towards The Mall as the lowest cost option, it was also the option with the most downsides.
- Strenuous workout. OK, if the workout is going to be strenuous (and based on my experience at my father-in-law's house last week it may very well be) I am going to be hot and sweaty. Do I want to wander around West Edmonton Mall with sweat pouring off me? No. Am I going to look suspicious? Yes. Am I going to feel extremely self-conscious and thus sabotage my workout? Probably. The only viable alternatives are the treadmill or the gym.
- Elapsed Time. If I am leaving the house I am adding time to the workout. Ten to fifteen minutes to get there and ten to fifteen minutes to get back. This can add twenty to thirty minutes of time to any workout effort. The best alternative is the treadmill with both the gym and West Edmonton Mall coming in second place.
- Privacy. I am not a very public person. Everything I do is very private. I don't sing in public. I don't draw attention to myself. I am very much an introvert. In the area of walking I can walk in public because people are not shoulder to shoulder with me looking at what I am doing. In this case the gym is the least comfortable solution due to my own insecurities.
- Increased Performance. What if I decide that running is actually what I want to do. Both the treadmill and the gym provide options for me to increase the tempo of my workout without looking out of place. West Edmonton Mall? Imagine a fat man running through the mall with sweat pouring off his head. I'd arrest him.
- Winter clothes. In the middle of winter I would be going to the mall in my winter coat. Where do I put the coat while I am doing my walk? A $3.50 locker? Wear it? While the mall works for summer days when the weather is not perfect, the idea of walking around the mall with a 10 pund winter coat is just not an acceptable approach.
For my personal use the treadmill made more sense with the Gym in second place. If we refer to cost than a Gym membership for the six winter months ($350 - $700) would pay for the treadmill in 2 - 4 years. The more "features" we want in a gym the faster the payback. For example, a dedicated locker or even towel service adds quickly to the cost and makes the treadmill pay for itself much faster.
So, there we go, my reasons for a treadmil..